Pinpointing the motivations of Donald Trump can be particularly challenging a month into the coordinated strikes by the U.S. and Israel on Iran.
However, it is evident that he is closely monitoring the oil markets.
Historically, a comment or social media update from the U.S. president has led to significant fluctuations in oil prices, as traders reacted to indicators suggesting either an escalation or de-escalation of the conflict.
In recent days, though, market participants seem to be increasingly doubtful regarding the impact of his statements.
As of late February, oil was trading around $72 per barrel, prior to the initiation of strikes on Iran. By 19 March, it reached a peak of $118 per barrel, and as of Friday afternoon, the price had stabilized just below $112—a marked increase from its pre-conflict levels.
The following highlights several instances from the past month where Trump's communications and market movements have appeared to interrelate—albeit with inconsistent outcomes.
Jonathan Raymond, an investment manager at Quilter Cheviot, remarks that energy prices have evolved into a reflection of broader geopolitical and economic risks, surging when Trump's language takes an aggressive tone and subsiding during less confrontational periods.
"Investors are attempting to gauge genuine uncertainty," he notes. "While markets may seem jittery or perplexed, they are actively managing event risks in real-time, with oil being central to these dynamics."
Navigating trading decisions can prove complex for investors, especially given that certain comments from Trump seem designed to influence oil prices rather than convey policy direction, according to Brian Szytel from the Bahnsen Group.
"There is a saying that the first casualty of war is truth," he explains. "I suspect that the back-and-forth rhetoric regarding productive negotiations versus the opposite is largely focused on manipulating oil prices."
On Thursday, shortly after U.S. stock markets experienced their most significant decline since the conflict in Iran began, Trump stated that discussions with Iran were progressing "very well" and that he was postponing military strikes on Iran's energy infrastructure until at least 6 April.
In spite of this, oil prices continued on an upward trajectory.
Jane Foley, head of FX strategy at Rabobank, indicates that market responses are "becoming more muted" due to the "huge gap" between Trump's assurances and the lack of a similar acknowledgment from Tehran.
"Given the perceptions at play, many investors cannot foresee a swift resolution to the conflict, leaving the markets in a state of unease."
Russ Mould, investment director at AJ Bell, observes that markets have grown accustomed to Trump "frequently shifting his stance in response to political, stock market, or economic challenges."
He notes, "A sense of skepticism, or even outright cynicism, appears to be creeping into market sentiment."
Share this story